Ordering Gateway
Choose How to Order from The Magpie Bakery
Start with the kind of order you need. We will show you which Magpie page or outside ordering service handles it before you leave this website.
Order from today's live menu
Use this path for the items and fulfillment choices currently shown by Magpie's same-day ordering service. The next button opens magpiebakerytogo.com in a new tab; that service's menu and checkout are the current source for availability.
Plan a future pickup
Use Magpie's future-order store to view the dates, pickup windows, and items that are currently offered for advance ordering. The next button opens Magpie's future-order store in a new tab.
Start a custom-cake inquiry
Custom cakes begin with an inquiry so the bakery can review the date and request. The next button opens Magpie's inquiry store in a new tab. An inquiry is not an order confirmation.
Start a custom-cake inquiry Read about custom cakes
Weddings, catering, and business gifts
These projects need a conversation about the occasion and timing. Review the relevant planning page, then contact the bakery using the method listed there.
Before you submit
Menus, dates, and fulfillment choices can change. Review the details presented by the ordering service before checkout, and keep its confirmation for your records. For help choosing a path, call (973) 291-6756.
Not sure which path fits?
Call the bakery and describe what you need, including the date if it is for an event.