Ordering Gateway
Choose How to Order from The Magpie Bakery
Start with the kind of order you need. We will show you which Magpie page or outside ordering service handles it before you leave this website.
Magpie keeps ordering deliberately simple: one live menu for today, and a direct conversation with the bakery for anything planned ahead. Each path below explains when to use it, and only the same-day menu ever leaves this website. If you are still deciding what to order in the first place, browse the menu categories first.
Order from today's live menu
When to use this: you want baked goods or café drinks today — a grab-and-go pickup on the way home, a same-day dessert, or a treat to pair with a coffee. Because the case rotates daily, this live menu is the only accurate picture of what is available right now.
The next button opens magpiebakerytogo.com in a new tab; that service's menu and checkout are the current source for availability and pricing.
Plan a future pickup
When to use this: your order is for a date, not for today — a weekend pie, a holiday table, a birthday breakfast, or anything you want waiting for you at the counter. Planned pickups are arranged directly with the bakery: send your date and list through the contact form on this website, or call (973) 291-6756, and Magpie confirms what is possible for your day.
The next button stays on this website and opens Magpie's contact form.
Start a custom-cake inquiry
When to use this: you want a decorated cake designed for your occasion — a birthday, shower, anniversary, or milestone — rather than an everyday cake ordered ahead. Custom cakes begin with an inquiry so the bakery can review the date and request before anything is committed; an inquiry is not an order confirmation.
The next button stays on this website and opens Magpie's contact form. Include your date, serving count, and design ideas so Magpie can respond with what is possible.
Start a custom-cake inquiry Read about custom cakes
Which path fits?
- You want something today — use the live same-day menu on magpiebakerytogo.com.
- You are shopping for a future date — send your date and list through the contact form, or call, and the bakery confirms the pickup with you.
- You want a decorated cake made for your occasion — start a custom-cake inquiry and wait for the bakery to confirm.
- You are planning a wedding, catering, or business gifts — begin with the planning pages below and reach out for a conversation.
- You are not sure — call (973) 291-6756 or send a message through the contact form on this website below, and the bakery will point you to the right path.
Special orders start with a conversation
Weddings, dessert tables, event catering, and corporate gifts are planned around your occasion, guest count, and timeline, so they never go through a standard checkout. Review the planning page that matches your event, then contact the bakery using the method listed there — the earlier the conversation starts, the more options stay open for your date.
- Plan wedding desserts — cakes and dessert tables for the big day.
- Explore catering and business gifts — offices, events, and client thank-yous.
- See every contact option — phone, email, and online forms in one place.
Prefer to write first? The next button opens the contact form on this website — a good starting point when your request does not fit a neat category yet.
Before you submit
Menus, dates, and fulfillment choices can change. Review the details presented by the ordering service before checkout, and keep its confirmation for your records. If a date or item you were hoping for is not listed, that is worth a phone call — reach the bakery at (973) 291-6756, or plan an in-person visit using the Visit page.
Good to know
Questions, answered
What is the difference between the same-day menu and ordering ahead?
The same-day menu on magpiebakerytogo.com shows what the bakery can hand you today — it is the live picture of the current case. Ordering ahead for a future date happens right here on this website: send a message through the contact form or call the bakery with your date, and Magpie confirms what is possible.
Is a custom-cake inquiry the same as placing an order?
No. An inquiry starts a review: the bakery looks at your date, serving needs, and design ideas, then confirms what is possible. Nothing is booked until Magpie responds and confirms the details with you.
Can I order over the phone instead of online?
Yes. Call (973) 291-6756 during bakery hours and describe what you need. A phone call is often the fastest way to sort out an unusual request or to check whether a specific item is in the case before you drive over.
How far ahead should I order for a holiday or event?
As soon as your date is set. Planned pickups are scheduled around the bakery's production calendar, so the earlier you send the date through the contact form or by phone, the more options stay open — especially for custom cakes, wedding desserts, and catering.
Does Magpie deliver, or is everything pickup?
Each ordering service shows its own fulfillment choices at checkout, so rely on what it presents for your order. The bakery's storefront is at 2-14 Riverside Square in Bloomingdale, NJ, and pickup there is always an option; call (973) 291-6756 if you are unsure which choice fits.
Not sure which path fits?
Call the bakery and describe what you need, including the date if it is for an event.