The Magpie Bakery Menu — Baked Fresh Daily

If it's in our case, it was baked here — by Melanie Stripeikis, with 30+ years of baking behind her, not shipped in from a commissary. That also means this page is a map, not a printout: the lineup shifts daily with the season and the morning's bake. For exactly what's available today, the online ordering menu is always current.

Pies & tarts

The Magpie's namesake habit: collecting good things and tucking them into a crust. Whole pies for the table and tarts for one, with fillings that follow the seasons — cream-pie classics like banana cream and chocolate cream make regular appearances on the ordering menu. If you need a pie for a specific dinner, order ahead online (allow at least a couple of hours for full-size pies) and it's boxed and waiting.

Sweet pastries

The morning case: croissants, turnovers, and cinnamon rolls, baked fresh that day. These are the ones that tend to disappear before lunch, so early birds get the pick of the tray.

Savory hand pies & pot pies

Lunch you can hold in one hand — and dinner you don't have to cook. The savory side of the ordering menu has featured the likes of chicken pot pie, chili queso pie, corned beef pie, and a plant-forward lentil vegetable pie; the lineup rotates, so check today's menu for what's in the case. A Magpie signature, and a good reason to time your errands around midday.

Donuts

Bakery donuts, made in-house — not a chain's par-baked ring. Grab one with a coffee at the counter, or a box for the breakroom.

Cookies

Cookies by the piece for the ride home, or arranged on a platter when you're feeding more than yourself — party platters live over on our catering page.

Custom cakes & cupcakes

Birthdays, showers, tiered centerpieces, and decorated cupcakes — designed with Melanie herself and baked to order. There's no order form for these; you talk to the baker. See custom cakes for how it works, or call (973) 291-6756 with your date.

Wedding dessert tables

Full dessert spreads for weddings — cannolis, napoleons, lemon bars, and bread pudding among them. Read about wedding desserts and then call to talk through your date.

Corporate gifts & catering trays

Custom logo-printed cookies for client gifts, plus catering trays for meetings and office parties. Details on the catering & corporate gifts page — these are arranged by phone.

Coffee, drinks & breakfast

Really good coffee and a case full of morning pastries make us a first stop for neighbors from Butler and Riverdale on their way through Bloomingdale. Visit our coffee and drinks page for the featured iced teas, matcha, and café details.

Vegan options

Plant-based baking, done in-house and rotating like everything else. See what to expect on our vegan bakery page, or call and ask what's vegan in the case today.

Why the menu changes daily

A rotating case is the trade-off for a bakery where everything is actually baked that morning. Nothing sits, nothing is reheated from a freezer — which is a big part of how the Magpie earned its 4.9-star rating across 317 Google reviews. Treat this page as the field guide, then order online to see today's case, or just come in and let the smell decide for you.