Call, Email, or Visit
Contact The Magpie Bakery
Reach the bakery directly, send a message, or start the inquiry that fits your request — this page matches each channel to the job it does best.
Which channel fits your question?
Magpie is a small bakery, so each way of reaching it has a clear job. Pick the one that matches what you need and your question lands in the right hands the first time:
- It's about today — call (973) 291-6756. Whether an item is in the case, a pickup question, today's hours: phones beat forms for anything time-sensitive.
- It can wait for a written reply — send an online message with the form below; it goes straight to the bakery.
- It's about a decorated cake — start a custom-cake inquiry so the bakery sees your date, serving count, and design ideas together.
- It's already answered somewhere — the FAQ page covers ordering, cakes, dietary, and visiting questions, and the Visit page has hours, directions, and first-visit tips.
Call the bakery
Calling is the direct line to the counter, and the best channel when your question is about today: confirming a specific bake before you drive over, checking holiday hours, sorting out an order already in motion, or figuring out which planning path fits an unusual request. Calls are answered during bakery hours.
Email Magpie
Email suits longer notes — attachments, inspiration photos, or details you want in writing. Please do not send payment-card details or other sensitive information by email.
Send a message
Fill in the form below and it goes straight to the bakery — no other website involved. Include the date and the best way to reach you.
Starting a custom-cake conversation
Decorated cakes don't go through a standard checkout — they begin with an inquiry the bakery reviews before anything is committed. Use the message form above with your date, serving count, and design ideas; the custom cakes page explains what to include so the first reply comes back with real answers.
When to expect a reply
An honest expectation: the people answering messages are the same people baking, so written messages and emails are read and answered during bakery hours rather than around the clock. A note sent in the evening is typically seen when the next bakery day begins. When timing is tight — a same-day question, a pickup on the way — skip the queue and call (973) 291-6756 instead. And if what you actually need is to place an order, the How to Order page routes you to the live service that handles it directly.
Visit or get directions
The Magpie Bakery2-14 Riverside Square, Bloomingdale, NJ 07403
Some conversations are simply better in person, with the case in view. Hours, the map, and first-visit tips live on the Visit page.
Good to know
Questions, answered
What is the fastest way to reach The Magpie Bakery for a same-day question?
Call (973) 291-6756 during bakery hours. A phone call reaches a person at the counter, which makes it the right channel for anything about today — whether an item is in the case, a pickup already in motion, or hours around a holiday.
How quickly does the bakery respond to messages?
Messages are read and answered during bakery hours by the same small team doing the baking, so a note sent overnight is seen when the bakery day starts. This website doesn't promise a specific turnaround; if the answer can't wait, calling is the reliable path.
Can I place an order through the contact form?
The form starts a conversation rather than a transaction. Same-day orders go through the live menu at magpiebakerytogo.com, while future pickups and decorated cakes are arranged directly with the bakery — the How to Order page walks through each path.
How do I get in touch about a custom cake?
Use the custom-cake inquiry form linked on this page and include your event date, roughly how many servings you need, and any design or flavor ideas. The bakery reviews the request and replies with what's possible — nothing is booked until Magpie confirms it with you.
Need help with an order?
Include the date and the best way to reach you when you contact the bakery.