Serving Customers from West Milford
A Bakery & Café near West Milford, NJ
The Magpie Bakery welcomes customers from West Milford at its Bloomingdale storefront. Use live directions and current ordering links before making the trip.
West Milford covers a huge sweep of the New Jersey Highlands — from Greenwood Lake down through miles of forest, lakes, and township roads. Out here, 'nearby' is relative, and a genuinely good bakery is the kind of stop worth building a drive around.
For many West Milford and Greenwood Lake customers, The Magpie Bakery in Bloomingdale is that stop: golden filled pastries and a real coffee on the way through, or a chocolate heart cake ordered ahead for someone's big day before heading back up into the Highlands.
Both towns are Passaic County, even if the landscape between them says otherwise. Because West Milford is so spread out, it pays to check the live menu and current hours before setting out — then let the live directions link handle whichever township road you're starting from.
One storefront, clearly identified
Magpie does not claim a separate West Milford location. The bakery and café is at 2-14 Riverside Square, Bloomingdale, NJ 07403. The Visit page has the current schedule, map, phone number, and a live directions link that accounts for your exact starting point.
Choose the right ordering path
The How to Order page separates three different needs: seeing today's live menu, planning a future pickup, and starting a custom-cake inquiry. Each button names the external Magpie property before opening it.
What neighbors pick up on a West Milford run
The bakery case rotates through the week, so no two trips from West Milford look exactly alike. Most visits revolve around the same handful of categories on the bakery menu — pies, tarts, pastries, donuts, cookies, and bars from a scratch kitchen — while the live ordering menu owns today's exact selection.
- Something for the table: fruit pies, crumb bars, tarts, and seasonal bakes from the rotating menu categories.
- Something for a celebration: a custom-cake inquiry started ahead of the date rather than grabbed on the way out.
- Something for the ride home: coffee, tea, and cold drinks poured at the café counter, to stay or to go.
A peek at past bakery cases
Bakery, café, and celebration planning
Beyond the everyday case, West Milford customers plan bigger occasions with Magpie: wedding dessert tables, catering trays and corporate gifts, and vegan bakery options (baked in a shared kitchen). Item availability changes, so the live menu remains the source for today's selection.
Nearby customer guides
Magpie also welcomes customers from Wanaque and Kinnelon. All of these guides point to the same Bloomingdale storefront.
For a current-menu question, call (973) 291-6756.
Good to know
Questions, answered
Is The Magpie Bakery located in West Milford?
No. The bakery's only storefront is at 2-14 Riverside Square, Bloomingdale, NJ 07403. Bloomingdale and West Milford both sit in Passaic County. This page helps West Milford customers plan a visit to that one Bloomingdale location.
How should I get directions from West Milford?
Use the live directions link on the Visit page. It uses your actual starting point and current traffic instead of a hard-coded travel-time claim.
Can I check the selection before leaving home?
Yes. The How to Order page separates the same-day menu, future pickup ordering, and custom-cake inquiry so you can choose the correct workflow.
What are the bakery's hours for a trip from West Milford?
Regular hours are Mon & Sun 8–3 · Tue–Sat 8–5. Holiday schedules can change, so check the Visit page or call (973) 291-6756 before making a special trip.
Planning a bakery stop from West Milford?
Check the current ordering choices, hours, address, and live directions first.