Pies worth gathering forOrder Thanksgiving pies online for pickup at The Magpie Bakery in Bloomingdale, NJ, or explore the full bakery and café menu on Menufy.

A destination bakery for North Jersey

The Magpie bakes from a single storefront at Riverside Square, but the morning line tells a bigger story. Neighbors walk over from Bloomingdale itself; regulars make the short hop from Butler, just over the borough line; families come down from Kinnelon and West Milford for weekend pies, birthday cakes, and a proper café stop.

Bloomingdale sits where Passaic, Morris, and Bergen counties meet, which makes the bakery an easy add to a Route 23 errand run or a stop on the way to the lakes and trails farther north — coffee and a croissant heading up, a boxed pie heading home.

If you're mapping your first trip, the areas we serve guide covers eight nearby towns, and the visit page has hours, parking notes, and live directions.

Plan your first visit

Start with the menu to see how the bakery and café categories work, skim the FAQ for quick answers on ordering, custom cakes, and vegan options, then use the visit page for hours, parking, and turn-by-turn directions to Riverside Square. Come hungry — the case does the rest.