The Magpie Bakery FAQ

The only Magpie storefront is at 2-14 Riverside Square, Bloomingdale, NJ 07403, in the Riverside Square plaza. The Visit page links live turn-by-turn directions from wherever you're starting.

Regular hours are Mon & Sun 8–3 · Tue–Sat 8–5. Around holidays the schedule can shift, so call (973) 291-6756 if your trip depends on exact timing.

Yes — one storefront serves both. The café counter pours coffee, tea, matcha, and cold drinks right beside the bakery case, so you can pair a drink with whatever catches your eye through the glass.

No. Walking in and shopping the case is the classic Magpie visit. The case rotates daily, though, so if you're driving over for one specific item, check the live same-day menu or call first.

The live same-day menu at magpiebakerytogo.com is the current source for today's items. This website describes the categories Magpie bakes; the live menu owns the day-to-day selection.

Same-day orders go through the live menu, which lists what is actually available right now. Future pickups are arranged directly with the bakery — send your date and list through the contact form on this website, or call, and Magpie confirms the order with you. The Order Online page walks through both paths.

Small-batch baking means popular items genuinely run out. The live menu updates as the day goes on, and for a must-have bake, ordering ahead through the contact form or by phone is the safer route.

This website doesn't promise delivery. Whatever fulfillment choices exist for a given order are the ones the ordering service shows at checkout, so review them there before you submit.

As soon as the date is real. A small bakery's calendar fills unevenly — some weekends book quickly — and the bakery can only confirm feasibility after seeing your date, serving count, and design direction. Starting early simply keeps more options open.

The event date, how many people the cake should serve, flavor preferences, and any inspiration photos or theme notes. With those in hand, the bakery can respond with real answers instead of a round of follow-up questions.

No. The inquiry starts a conversation; the order is confirmed only after the bakery reviews the date and design and replies. Until then, nothing is held.

Yes — wedding cakes, dessert tables, and combinations of both, for couples across North Jersey. The wedding desserts page explains how that planning conversation works, and the cake gallery shows real past Magpie work.

Yes. Dessert trays, cookie platters, and bakery boxes for offices, parties, and events are planned directly with the bakery so the selection matches the occasion and the headcount.

Branded and logo cookies are part of the catering-and-gifts conversation. Reach out with the artwork, quantity, and date, and the bakery will confirm what it can produce.

Call (973) 291-6756 or send a message through Magpie's contact form with the date, expected headcount, and the kind of spread you're imagining. The bakery replies to shape the details with you.

Vegan items rotate through the case rather than living on a fixed menu. The vegan options page explains how the rotation works, and the live menu or a phone call answers what's available on a given day.

Wheat is handled throughout the kitchen, and Magpie doesn't market an allergen-free environment, so nothing on this site should be read as a gluten-free promise. If gluten matters to your order, talk with the bakery directly about what's possible.

Nuts are used in the same kitchen and on shared equipment as everything else, and no allergen-free claim is made. Contact the bakery before ordering so you can decide with full information.

Ask the bakery directly — call, send a message, or ask at the counter. Because the case rotates, a person at the bakery is a better source than any static list on this website.