Bloomingdale, NJ · Order for pickup

Holiday Pies

Thanksgiving Pie Pre-Orders Are Now Open!

Complete your holiday table with one of Magpie Bakery's signature handcrafted pies. Made from scratch with buttery crusts and the finest ingredients, they're the perfect finishing touch to your Thanksgiving feast.

Pre-orders are available now for in-store pickup on Tuesday, November 24th and Wednesday, November 25th.

We will also be open Thanksgiving morning from 8:00 AM to 12:00 PM with a limited selection of pies and baked goods available for walk-in purchase while supplies last.

Pre-order early to reserve your favorites.

Thanksgiving pie preorders are open. Order online by Monday, November 23, 2026, and pick up at the bakery on Tuesday, November 24 or Wednesday, November 25.

Looking for coffee, pastries, or the rest of today’s menu? That’s a separate order: Full menu on Menufy

Thanksgiving pie ordering at a glance

What you can order
The pies listed on this page, at the prices shown on each pie.
How to order
Add pies to your cart, choose a pickup date on each pie, and check out on this website.
Orders close
Monday, November 23, 2026
Pickup dates
Tuesday, November 24 or Wednesday, November 25, 2026
Where to pick up
The Magpie Bakery, 2-14 Riverside Square, Bloomingdale, NJ 07403

Pie ordering questions

Can I add coffee or pastries to my pie order?

No. Pies are ordered and paid for on this website. The full everyday menu is a separate order with its own cart and checkout on Menufy: Full menu on Menufy

When is my pickup confirmed?

Your pickup date is the one you choose on each pie before checkout; it is saved with that pie in your order. Call the bakery if you need to know holiday pickup hours before you come in.

What if I miss the ordering deadline?

Online preorders close Monday, November 23, 2026. After that, call the bakery to ask whether any pies are available.

Are the pies allergen-free?

Ask the bakery about ingredients before ordering if allergies are a concern.

Three ways to order

Pick the path that fits your day

Planned pickup

Plan a future pickup

Shop the items and pickup dates the bakery has opened for advance orders.

Shop order-ahead →

Celebrations

Start a custom-cake inquiry

Share your date, serving count, and ideas. The bakery replies with what’s possible; an inquiry isn’t a booking until Magpie confirms.

Start an inquiry →

Weddings, catering, or business gifts? Start with a conversation →

Warm from the oven, ready when you are

Choose the same-day menu, plan a future pickup, or start a custom-cake inquiry from one clear ordering guide.

Choose how to order →Call (973) 291-6756